Danville Board of Education hears from supporters of elementary reshuffling plan
Published 10:54 am Thursday, September 29, 2016
There was a packed house at Danville High School Wednesday night for a discussion of the proposal to make Hogsett Elementary School a kindergarten and first-grade center while making Jennie Rogers Elementary School a preschool and central office.
The three-hour special called Danville Board of Education meeting was to give the board the opportunity to hear about the process behind the Local Planning Committee’s reasoning behind the proposed plan.
Many in attendance at the last meeting expressed support for changing the plan and making Jennie Rogers the kindergarten and first grade center instead. But a majority of Wednesday’s speakers expressed support for the plan as it stands.
“The board will not be taking any action tonight,” board Chairman Lonnie Harp said. “We will be listening to the people who are here. We’ve been getting emails from people — we welcome that. We’ll be taking some time to digest what we learn in here tonight. Each of us probably have some questions for the folks who have been advising this process. We’re just trying to get questions and clarifications on the process and hear from folks here tonight.”
The current LPC was established in April and met 11 times over the course of five months, Superintendent Keith Look said. The committee is formed of 20 members, including Look as a non-voting member, parents, teachers, school staff, community members and a planning and zoning official.
The LPC was charged with three tasks:
• make a determination of the particular locations of the preschool, kindergarten and first grade students;
• make a plan that maximizes the use of state money for development;
• make good use of the “second nickel” from the district’s nickel tax;
“Not every LPC has to make such concrete decisions, but from a timing standpoint, this was the task,” Look said.
Look explained that the committee closely examined six plans, which included:
• splitting into two preschool through first-grade centers at Hogsett and Jennie Rogers, with one of the schools housing the central office instead of preschoolers;
• making either of the two schools a preschool through first-grade center and the other a central office and a special programs center; and
• making either of the two schools a kindergarten and first-grade center, while making the other the preschool and central office.
“There are a whole host of permutations,” Look said to the crowd gathered, but added that these are the ones they narrowed their choices to.
Those choices were then examined by whether or not there would be cost to implement them and if there would be a need for continuing funds. Through this process, the proposed plan was selected, Look said.
To convert Jennie Rogers to a preschool through first grade center would cost about $7 million; to make it a kindergarten and first-grade center would cost about $6 million; and to make it a preschool and central office would cost about $3 million.
To convert Hogsett to a preschool through first grade center would cost about $5 million; to make it a kindergarten and first-grade center would cost about $4 million; to make it a preschool and central office would cost about $3 million.
The proposed plan of converting Jennie Rogers into the central office and the home of the district’s growing preschool program and converting Hogsett into the district’s kindergarten and first-grade center is estimated at $8 million.
Amanda Goodwin expressed her concern that her youngest child would have to attend three different schools by the time she hits second grade.
“Transitions are hard on all of us; they’re especially difficult for young children,” Goodwin said. “The stress of these transitions affects young kids’ social interactions, their competence and their learning. These effects are magnified in our most vulnerable learners.”
Sarah Berry and Clay Albright spoke together. The two siblings are Danville graduates and current Danville parents.
While both said they loved the neighborhood school that they had the opportunity to experience at Toliver, Berry and Albright said they both supported the committee’s proposal.
“There are a lot of people on LPC that I highly respect, so I respect their decision, whatever it is. I hope that you will all move forward with their recommendation,” she said.
An issue with parking had been brought up regarding Hogsett, but Berry said that was never an issue for her, a Hogsett parent.
“That’s kind of our only outreach into the south side of town,” Albright said. “If we’re ‘all means all,’ then I feel like … we can’t say ‘all means all,’ — only if you live in downtown, where we already have Bate, Danville High School, Jennie Rogers and Toliver. I feel like we need to maintain an anchor in the south side of town.”
Albright also pointed out the potential for savings by following the plan, and the potential for expansion that would be possible at Hogsett versus Jennie Rogers.
Hogsett principal Leo Labrillazo, who also served on the LPC, spoke in favor of the plan, citing the cost difference and noting the savings would be money the district might be able to use elsewhere.
He also echoed the statements that the south side of Danville needs that representation.
“I wish that this decision didn’t feel so much like there was going to be a winner and a loser, because the truth in the matter is that there isn’t a person in this room that doesn’t ultimately want what is best for the students, teachers and families of Danville Schools,” Labrillazo said.
Toliver kindergarten teacher Lisa Denny addressed the board, armed with a letter from kindergarten and first-grade teachers at Toliver and Hogsett, casting their support behind the plan, due in part to the larger classrooms at Hogsett Elementary.
Barbara Howe, a parent of a student from Jennie Rogers Elementary and a teacher at Hogsett, urged the board and everyone present to take their emotions out of the discussion.
“When we look at the figures, when we look at the recurring costs down the road, when we look at the ability to expand — I don’t know how we can look at anything else,” she said.
Follow Kendra Peek on Twitter, @knpeek.
SO YOU KNOW
The Danville Board of Education will have a working session on Oct. 10 at Bate Middle School and a regular meeting on Oct. 17 at Danville High School. Both meetings begin at 6 p.m.
Email addresses for all the board members are available online at bit.ly/2dcYiYT.
The next step is for the board of education to approve the Local Planning Committee’s plan and send it to the Kentucky Board of Education for approval, or to reject it and send it back to the LPC for changes.